Friday, July 4, 2025

Retro Reviews: Led Zeppelin II

 

I decided to launch a new series to imagine myself as a critic at the end of the 60s and start of the 70s, and to rectify certain reviews from Rolling Stone magazine and Creem. This not meant to be contrarian, but to offer a more balanced perspective. All the albums reviewed are indeed classic albums. 


Led Zeppelin II
(1969)

*****

Producer: Jimmy Page

Musicians: Robert Plant, Jimmy Page, John Paul Jones, John Bonham

Songs or music: Whole Lotta Love, What Is And What Should Never Be, The Lemon Song, Thank You, Heartbreaker, Living Loving Maid (She’s Just A Woman), Ramble On, Moby Dick, Bring It On Home

By Matthew Anthony Allair

    After the launch of Zeppelin’s debut, they have created a lot of excitement, and especially during the North American summer tour where they have connected more than in Europe. I am not surprised, this new band just excites the average record buyer, and the new album might just solidify it more. The Jeff Beck Group’s second album, “Beck-Ola” went in a different vibe, and there is less comparison between the two acts now. The new album takes the best elements from Zeppelin’s debut, and improves on it, and it makes for one exciting listen. Failure offers a million explanations, but success rarely needs explaining.

    After a stutter, the album opens with the swagger of “Whole Lotta Love”, a fairly simple track as a song, but it makes for a great record, and a psychedelic middle section of percussion, sounds and shrieks, before building into a crescendo. “What Is And What Never Should Be” starts off with a laid back fusion jazz nod of a groove, before heading into overdrive with the choruses. “The Lemon Song” plays with every standard blue cliché, yet keeps it fresh. Let’s address the complaints I have seen that the band borrows from a lot of blues sources and doesn’t credit them, perhaps valid, but then again, the band seems to want to reshape what the blues actually means. Let’s also address the other issue, the repetitive nature of some songs from the last album, it looks to me that the method is to place the listener into a certain state, good or for bad, it’s up for the reader to decide. The next track, the lovely “Thank You” opens with some nice organ and layered guitars, and one of the most heart felt vocals from Plant.

    Side two opens with the sonic fire of “Heartbreaker”, and a pretty dazzling middle showcase section. “Living Loving Maid” seems to be the heavy pop number on the record, and probably the lightest track. The acoustic “Ramble On” has some spry percussion, before jumping into another heavy chorus. The drum show case “Moby Dick” opens with a nice grove before Bonham can dazzle with his light and share style of drumming, this track might even rival Cream’s “Toad”, which for some might seem unthinkable. Plants Harmonica is back for the slow blues groove of “Bring It On Home” that morphs into the raunchy groove that will leave you exhilarated. Great playing and vocals throughout.  Bonham’s drumming is outstanding overall, for example John swings like mad on “Whole Lotta Love”, you can tell when a drummer has a jazz influence, or influenced by players like Clyde Stubblefield, such players can often lift up a rock arrangement

    This band is quickly shaping up to be what might be the defining sound of the next decade, no wonder why certain music critics and industry peers are shook up. Ignore the bad notices you read, this has surpassed the promise of the first record. Incidentally, the track listing on the audio cassette is slightly different. This is as great of an album as you will ever get – all hail the new sound, Man.

A very special Raspberry to John Mendelsohn. 😏

No comments:

Post a Comment