Derek and the Dominos: Layla and
other assorted Love Songs (1970)
Clapton’s Muse, and it’s very strange
legacy
Essay and overview by Matthew Anthony Allair
Personal Connection
Eric Clapton is one of the most celebrated rock and blues guitarists of the last seventy years, but he is also full of contradictions, as well as polarizing, depending on how you view him. Personally, he isn’t my favorite; I don’t have the same connection with him as I do with Jimi Hendrix. For me, he isn’t as inventive as Jimmy Page, and I think it’s fair to argue that Jeff Beck - for his range and adventurousness -is the best British guitar player of his generation. But you have to contend with Clapton’s influence on nearly everyone. We have a tale of a man who was in love with his best friends wife and tried to woo her. A man who felt entrapped with the bemouth that was Cream, broke out, only to be entrapped with the machinery of Blind Faith. A man who was lifted up by an RNB duo who believed in him, and a duo who connected him to a lot of great musicians. A man who was galvanized by two musicians who compelled him to some his best guitar playing and singing, and a Stax based producer who believed in the vision.
When I was in high school in Corte Madera, CA in the mid-eighties, my Dad made certain I was exposed to the highlights of Clapton’s work, he gave me a vinyl of Cream’s Best compilation, and I was soon given a Vinyl of John Mayall’s Blues Breakers with Clapton, sometime after I was given a Vinyl of Blind Faith with its controversial cover. I think the last vinyl I got from him was the two disc vinyl of Layla. It was impressive and impactful, the album, but I think my respect for it grew as I got older. After I was in a JC, and before I went to a proper college. I was at a music store part time, when I picked up the CD remaster of Layla in 1990, and I think my respect for the album and its experience, grew.
The History
The journey with how Clapton evolved is interesting, and the tale with all of the other players, producers, and figures who helped shape what the album became. Eric is an enormously popular figure who gave as much as he took, all of their origins are fascinating to behold.
Eric Patrick Clapton was March 30 1945 in the village of Ripley just north of London, to an underage girl named Patricia, her father had died when she was a child and she was taken in by Rose and Jack Clap. Patricia has a brief romance with a Canadian airmen named Edward Fryer, who was already married and had a wife in Canada and he went home after the war. Due to the stigma of having a child out of wedlock, Rose and Jack passed themselves off as Eric’s parents, with Patricia the older sister. It wasn’t until the period between 6 to 9 years of age that the truth was slowly revealed to Eric. Pattie Boyd would notate the impact of the development:
“It was not until Eric was nine and Pat reappeared in his life that he learned who his real mother was. He was angry – and I think that anger was always inside him, coloring his relationships with women. He never trusted them and he couldn’t understand the concept of having a platonic relationship with a woman; if no sex was involved, he didn’t see the point.”
This issue didn’t just affect his relationships but explained his willingness to jump from one band to another, as would play out. As a child Clapton had a happy one with Rose and Jack, he was popular with other kids, and in spite of his family’s lower working-class background, probably due to guilt, his grandparents did spoil him. Nevertheless, Eric did become an isolated child, a loner. As he would later observe about growing up in the late 50s:
“I wanted to be a beatnik before beatniks were even heard of Ripley. I was the Village Beatnik.”
By the time Eric was growing up by 1956, he had already discovered Elvis Presley, his friend John, whom like Clapton was less into cricket and more into clothes and 78 records helped turned him on to “Hound Dog”, the neighboring kids called Eric and John the “Loonies”. Eric got his first record player around this period, when he had access to a friend’s Television, it was a revelation as he has commented on.
“One night they had Buddy Holly on the show, and I thought I died and gone to heaven. That was when I saw my first Fender guitar. Jerry Lee Lewis was singing “Great Balls Of Fire” and the bass player had a Fender Precision Bass. It was like seeing an instrument from outer space, and I said to myself; “That’s the future – that’s what I want. Suddenly I realized I was in a Village that was never going to change, yet there on TV was something out of the future. And I wanted to go there.”
By the time Clapton moved to a new school district, the teachers recognized he had artistic talent, plus he got his first guitar, as much as it oversized for his small frame, he started to move away from skiffle which was the trend. By the time he moved to Kingston School of Art. Clapton was listening to Muddy Waters, Big Bill Broonzy, and learning Bessie Smith numbers. A school friend first exposed him to Robert Johnson. Eric started to meet more people who knew about Muddy Waters and Howlin’ Wolf, record collectors who would hold club nights who exposed Eric to John Lee Hooker, Little Walter, and Lightning Hopkins. He had been accepted into Kingston in their graphics department, but his school work started to suffer as his music obsessions grew. For a time he was moved into the glass department where he learned engraving and sandblasting, but he was eventually kicked out of Kingston, much to the shame of his grandparents.
Eric was expected to work if he stayed in with his relatives, he worked as a brick layer, kept up his playing until his Washburn was completely destroyed in an accident, he was able to get a Kay, something affordable that looked like a Gibson ES-335 Electric, a friend first turned him onto Robert Johnson, while he waited to get an Amplifier. He had an attraction / repulsion to Johnson, it was intimidating but it pulled him in, he slowly learned how to play Johnson’s riffs and got better as he absorbed Hooker, Waters, Berry, Big Bill Broonzy and Jimmy Reed.
By January of 1963, Clapton met up with, at a pub in New Maven, Tom McGuinness, a guitarist from the Roosters and Eric joined the band, they rehearsed and learned Chuck Berry, Muddy Waters and Larry Williams tunes, but this period was the first time that Eric heard Freddy King and the instrumental “Hideaway”, this would have a huge impact on Clapton. The band rehearsed more then they played, they mostly played the Ricki Ticki Club circuit, after the Roosters folded, Tom helped get Clapton a new gig with Casey Jones and the Engineers, eventually, Clapton met Giorgio Gomelsky, a manager with an association with Brian Epstein, like Andrew Loog Oldham before him with the Rolling Stones, he was on his way to signing The Yardbird’s. Clapton was at a Kingstown party when he crossed paths with Keith Reif and after their other guitarist had to drop out, Clapton joined the Yardbirds with Reif, Chris Dreja, Paul Samwell-Smith, and Jim McCarty. By 1964, the band had signed a record deal with Columbia records, and soon recorded “I Wish You Would” – they were on their way.
Giorgio wanted the band to wear uniforms, and he knew how image conscious Clapton was, Eric was given the job of designing them. Eric came up with black suits, with jackets that had, instead of a standard lapel, something more like a shirt lapel, which buttoned almost to the top, they were made up and black and beige mohair, at a tailor shop in Soho. Giorgio could control Eric to a degree, but only so far. The Yardbirds by 1964 were playing 200 gigs and playing on package tours with Jerry Lee Lewis and the Ronettes. By the end of that December, the band had been invited to perform as a support act for The Beatles during their Christmas shows at the Hammersmith Odeon in London. As Clapton noted:
“Hanging out backstage at the Odeon was where I had my first meeting with The Beatles. Paul played the ambassador, coming out to meet us and say hello. I remember him playing us the tune of “Yesterday”, which was half written, and asking everyone what they thought. George and I hit it off right away. He seemed to like what I did, and we talked shop a lot. He showed me his collection of Gretch guitars, and I showed him my light gauge strings, which I always bought from a shop called Clifford Essex on Earlham Street, I gave him some, and this was the start of what was to become a long friendship:”
By early 1966, Robert Stigwood had under contract two acts, Eric Clapton from John Mayall’s band and Jack Bruce and Ginger Baker from the Graham Bond Organization, and the formation of Cream would lead to him managing them. A year later, he would sign an Australian act - the Gibb brothers, The Bee Gees, this expanded Robert’s reach. Robert would produce Cream’s first album, Fresh Cream, this arrangement wasn’t all that different than Andrew Loog Oldham producing The Rolling Stones for a period. But first was Eric’s journey with John Mayall.
***
Duane Allman was born in November 1946, his brother Gregg was born a year later in December 1947, their father Willis - didn’t have an easy life - after several attempts Willis joined the Army, while living Rocky Mount, North Carolina, Willis courted Geraldine Robbins, they were married in December 1941 right on the heels of the Pearl Harbor attack. Willis was offered a commission by 1949 and his family was sent to Port Story, on the outskirts of Norfolk, Virginia, the boys were around 2 and 4 years old, when their father got into a scuffle along with an Army friend, and their father, Willis, was killed, a trial was conducted in 1951, the assailant would remain in prison for 24 years. Geraldine stuck it out, she went to college, while the boys lived with their father’s parents, when she graduated in 1957, she was able to take her sons and move to Daytona Beach. Duane emerged from his father’s Murder with an attitude, bur he was also very chiasmic, Duane spent less time at school, he used his first earnings to buy a Harley 165, and as soon as he was able to, he bought, with a discount deal, a Silvertone electric guitar, he and his brother Gregg would often argue.
Whenever they visited their grandparents in Tennessee, they would be taken to the Grand Old Opry, when they heard Jackie Wilson, B.B. King and Otis Redding, both brothers knew they had to get into that scene. Yet Duane dropped out of school before High School; he had one mission to be a rock guitarist. While the grandmother was afraid that Cregg would follow the same path, in 1962, she sent Cregg to the Castle Hights Military Academy, that held things up for a couple of years, Duane and Cregg joined the Escorts in 1965, a band that opened for The Beach Boys for a show. The brothers formed their own band the Allman Joys around that period, by the end of 1965, Duane was given a deferment to serve in Viet Nam, a protection due to father’s past death. Gregg was also in danger of getting drafted, but before his physical, Gregg shot himself in the foot, a light wound, and was disqualified, and he never walked with a limp.
Buddy Killen, who had some fame for discovering Joe Tex, recorded a single for Allman Joy for a small label, it went nowhere. A new version of the band was formed in 1967 under the name Hour Glass, that band even opened for The Doors, and played at the Whiskey a Go Go in southern California. By 1968, Hour Glass even managed to record at a studio in Alabama, Muscle Shoals, they recorded B.B. King and John Lee Hooker, they even managed to record a second album under that name, The Power of Love, with liner notes written by Neil Young. It went nowhere, and Duane was getting desperate when Wilson Pickett came into the picture. Jerry Wexler was assembling a new Muscle Shoals rhythm section for the album and need a great guitarist, thus Duane was hired. In fact other African American musicians could not believe Duane was white. He played on, not only the single, but album of Hey Jude.
Even though Wexler didn’t produce the album, which was co-produced by Tom Dowd, he did sign a contract for Duane to do session work for Atlantic, the single was a top ten charter, and the attention gave Duane clout he didn’t have before. Duane did session work for Arthea Franklin, and Delaney soon after. In fairly short order, Duane assembled the players that would make up The Allman Brothers Band. 2nd guitarist Dickie Betts, Jammie Johanson, Butch Trucks, Berry Oakley, The last step was getting his brother Gregg out of a Liberty records contract selling songs in California, but he joined up with the new band. There was a recording deal offer from Phil Walden and the Capricorn label, but the band had to relocate to Macon, Georgia. Their debut album was released in 69, and their second album Idlewild South was released in 1970, both didn’t sell big numbers, but momentum was building by the time Clapton would see the band and meet Duane.
***
Tom Dowd was born October 1925 in Manhattan, New York, he grew up in a musical family as his father was a concertmaster an stage manager on Broadway, and his mother an Sorbonne-trained Opera singer – soprano. He grew up playing Tuba, Piano, Violin and String bass. Tom grew into a tall and Gangly man, at around 16 in 1942, he was recruited out of New York City’s prestigious Stuyvesant High School for the band at Columbia University, as well as continued his education at City College of New York, while at Columbia he was employed at the Physics department. By 18 he was drafted into the Military as a Sargent, and was involved in the clandestine Manhattan Project. He has assumed that with much of his work on the project, he could go back to Columbia to finish his degree and become a nuclear physicist, but due to the classified nature of the work, the university didn’t recognize it, and he didn’t continue his career goals. However, he did take a job at a Classical music studio until he was employed at Atlantic Records. In 1947, a women came in to the studios with an odd, folk flavored piece, Eileen Barton’s “If I Knew You Were Comin’ I’d’ve Baked You a Cake” became a hit single in 1950, and Dowd became a free lance staff engineer for the label. Ahmet Ertegun and Jerry Wexler took a chance on Dowd and he became their sole staff engineer from 1954 onward for years.
Dowd was an innovator for Atlantic; he transformed the label from single track recording to Stereo, he pioneered the use of ¼ Inch tape and adjusted the sound with eight tracks before it was considered by others in the music business. He recorded Otis Redding’s Otis Blue album and Aretha Franklin’s I Never Loved A Man The Way I Loved You. It was Dowd’s idea to cut Ray Charles’s “What I’d Say” into two parts. Things changed as the situation with Wexler evolved and Dowd took a job and moved his Family to Miami, to work at Criteria Recording, he had morphed into a full-fledged freelance Producer now in his own right, he would often work with musicians, guiding them. He got involved with The Allman Brother’s Band second album Idlewild South. During a session, Tom got the call from Eric’s management, Stigwood, informing Tom that Clapton had started a new band, and they wanted to have him Produce. Duane Allman stumbled into the room right after the call was made and Allman, being a fan of Clapton, wanted to meet him. Duane just assumed he would just watch at the upcoming sessions; few knew what would happen.
The paring of Clapton and Allman would become one of the most serendipitous moments in rock music.
***
Pattie Ann Boyd was born on March 1944 to Colin “Jock” Ina Langdon Boyd and Diana Frances nee Drysdale, they initially lived in Somerset. She was the first of three children, her brother. The moved to Scotland, where Colin was born in 1946, and her sister Jenny was born in 1947 when they lived in Surrey, After Jock’s discharge from the Royal Air Force, the family moved to Nairobi from 1948 until 1953, the youngest Paula was born in 1951 at a hospital in Kenya. Pattie has described some of her happiest experiences came from her time in Kenya, but the family were full of secrets and disfunction. Pattie was attending by eight a boarding school, Nakuru School in Nairobi, on a Christmas break in 1953, she learned her parents had divorced. Diana had discovered that Jock was having an affair, thus prompted the sudden divorce, but the secrecy would continue soon afterwards. Diane introduced Pattie and her siblings to Bobbie Gaymer-Jones as their ‘new father’, but they would later learn that Bobbie didn’t tell his parents about Diana until they were already married – they couldn’t contest a relationship with a woman will multiple kids. Pattie ended up with two half-brothers from the marriage David and Robert. But the extended family kept moving from one town or country to another. Pattie didn’t attend Diana and Bobbie’s wedding - she was in school. Bobbie was strict, controlling and he didn’t know how to handle the kids. Prior to the marriage they were raised by servants in the past, it was an adjustment. Bobbie was known for beating the kids, they learned to fend for themselves.
By the time of March 1961, Pattie was seventeen and was on her way to being independent. She would learn with some shock that summer; that Bobbie wanted to divorce Diana. While Pattie was in South Kensington She had an opportunity to be a Beautician for Elizabeth Arden, but she found it deadly boring. One day a client came in and asked Pattie if she ever thought about being a model, soon arrangements were made with an in house photographer Anthony Norris to take test shots. Through contacts, one of the top modeling agencies were reached, Cherry Marshall, yet finding work as a model was not easy, she had to tie herself over from her brother Colin, or friends, but she started to network with other models. During the period she started to get work, she also started to date photographer Eric Swayne. She was helping to break new ground with the modeling clothing she would wear, a lot of ground was being made with the culture around her.
By 1964, Cherry Marshall pressed her to do a casting session with Richard Lester and Walter Shenson, she didn’t want to do it as she was already working with photographer, Dudley Harris, bur she agreed to do it, she assumed it was for a television commercial, when she saw the rows of other models in attendance, the whole affair was top secret as on one knew it was for first Beatles movie. The agency wouldn’t let her turn it down, she didn’t follow The Beatles and didn’t care much, She was soon be in the train sequence, and held the best impression of George Harrison from their fateful meeting, George made a proposition that lead to a dinner date, she broke it off with Eric, and she and George had a slow courtship. She soon became part of the Beatles girlfriends and wives inner circle. Patti was in love with George, these were the halcyon days, the idyllic days, they would be married several weeks in January 1966. At some point in 1967, before Brian Epstein’s passing, he hosted a party where Patti met Eric Clapton first met. He and George were already becoming close friends.
Pattie was platonically impressed with Eric when she saw him at a Cream concert at the Saville Theatre, as she noted:
“He was incredibly exciting to watch. I was in a box next to Tony King, who worked for the Beatles, and he kept saying, “Oh, my God.” He looked wonderful on stage, very sexy, and played beautifully. But when I met him afterward he didn’t behave like a Rock star; he was surprisingly shy and reticent.”
Pattie’s sister Paula went to a Delaney & Bonnie around 1969, and that was the beginning of Paula getting entangled with Eric. The couple were already in trouble around the time that Friar Park was purchased that year, but the passion from both Patti and George to restore the estate acted as a temporary distraction. By 1970, Clapton was casually going out with Alice Harlech as well, but after being inspired by the Persian writer Nizam’s “The Story of Layla Majnun”, Clapton wrote “Layla” and played it for Pattie, Soon after, after a party, George confronted Pattie and Eric, where Eric confessed his feelings for Pattie at a garden. Enraged, George made Pattie leave with him that evening.
***
Eric Clapton grew unhappy in The Yardbirds, even prior to their second album, In Fairness, both The Yardbirds and The Rolling Stones blues material was fairly similar – British acts found ways to distill American blues with a fresh spirit, but Eric was looking for something to Chicago blues, Eric didn’t care for the pop leaning of “For Your Love”, which had bongos and the Harpsicord, but it wasn’t all just musical differences. Eric and Paul Samwell-Smith had philosophical differences when it came to class,
Eric’s
experiences with John Mayall were revealing and opened him up, as he noted:
“Modern Chicago Blues became my new mecca. It was a rough, electric sound, spearheaded by people like Howlin’ Wolf, Muddy Waters, and John Lee Hooker, who had come up from the Delta to record for labels like Chess. The leading guitar players of this genre were Otis Rush, Buddy Guy, Elmore James, Hubert Sumlin, and Earl Hooker, to name a few. It perfectly suited our lineup of guitar, bass, drums and keyboard. John played Piano, Hammond Organ, rhythm guitar. On drums we had Hughie Flint, who would go to form a band with Tom McGuinnes called McGuiness-Flint. I played lead guitar, and the bass player was John McVie, who later formed Fleetwood Mac with Mick Fleetwood. Not only was a brilliant bass player, but he was an incredibly funny man, with a very dark, cynical sense of humor.”
John Mayall not only acted as a mentor, but due to the fact he was older, married with kids, he acted as a stabilizing force for Clapton. The rest of the band saw Mayall as a schoolmaster, and they all knew to not try his patience all that much. Soon after Eric joined, he and Mayall sized an opportunity to record with Bob Dylan at a session with Tom Wilson, but it didn’t pan out. Clapton had some incredible experiences with Mayall. Even prior to working with Producer Mike Vernon, Clapton recalled:
“It was an incredible life, and at times I didn’t believe it was happening. One night, for example, Mike Vernon, who owned Blue Horizon records, asked me to go down to a studio to do some session work, and I found myself playing with Muddy Waters and Otis Spann, two of my all time heroes. I was absolutely terrified, but not because I felt that I couldn’t carry my weight musically. I just didn’t know how to behave around these guys. They were incredible.”
Even after Clapton had left and was replaced with Peter Green, he still was brought on board to record the seminal blues breakers album released in June 1966, The Beano cover. Eric’s work with John Mayall was ground-breaking when released, the pairing of the Gibson Les Paul and the Marshall amp set the template for British and American rock. But outside movement was driving him to help form Cream. For a period, Eric was caught between loyalties. It should have been straight forward, but it wasn’t.
Cream’s launch was messy, the trio rehearsed in secret, even John Mayall didn’t know Eric was leaving the Blues breakers, prior to Mayall’s recruitment of Peter Green, Ginger Baker accidently broke the news to a reporter from Melody Maker in an interview, Jack Bruce was furious, and John Mayall was extremely upset when he learned about the upcoming departure. But after two years, Cream had rapidly started to implode, as Eric noted, just at their height in 1968:
“Musically, I was fed up with the virtuoso thing. Our gigs had become nothing more than an excuse for us to show off as individuals, and any sense of unity we might have had when we had started seemed to have gone out the window. We were suffering from an ability to get along. We would just run away from each other. We never socialized together and never really shared ideas anymore…We were immature and incapable of putting aside our differences.”
I would argue that Clapton benefited the most when he was with John Mayall. John was a mentor, he fostered Clapton’s development as a lead player, and he encouraged Clapton to take his first lead vocal with “Ramblin’ On My Mind”. Clapton should have stayed with Mayall for several more albums, then again Peter Green may not have come into the picture, and Fleetwood Mac may have never existed. The trajectory of Cream may have also been very different as well. But Clapton became trapped in a way that was the machine known as Cream - the staggering egos and conflicts between Jack Bruce and Ginger Baker are the stuff of legend - and their window of being seen as the preeminent British blues power trio only lasted until The Jimi Hendrix Experience broke onto the scene at the start of 1967. On paper, Clapton working with Steve Winwood should have been perfect, they seemed to be in sync, but Blind Faith became a problem once Ginger Baker joined. Clapton wanted to focus on song craft, but of course Ginger was always going to focus on instrumental prowess.
The Band’s Music From Big Pink album galvanized Clapton towards wanting a new direction, and Clapton’s association with Delaney and Bonnie, gave Eric a new focus, Delaney producing Clapton’s first solo record helped to point to a new way. George Harrison had joined Delaney & Bonnie on part of their tour, and it had all been such a contrast to George’s Beatle experience. Eric’s sessions with his friend George Harrison on the project All Things Must Pass demonstrated the balance between song craft and instrumental prowess. Eric recalled:
“George was working on his solo album, All Things Must Pass, and one day he asked if the Tulsa guys and I would play on it. I knew he had Phil Spector producing for him, so we made a deal whereby he would get Spector to produce a couple of tracks for us in return for having the use of our band for his album…We recorded two songs with him, “Roll It Over” and “Tell The Truth”, at Abbey Road Studios before turning ourselves over to George as our session musicians…His method of working was to get a lot of players in a room and have them all playing at the same time, creating the famous “Wall Of Sound””
George had assembled an all-star cast of players for his solo project, Ringo Starr, Gary Wright, Billy Preston, Klaus Voormann, Pete Drake, the boys from Badfinger, Eric on Lead, and Delaney & Bonnie’s backing players. Clapton forming Derek and The Dominos was bound to happen.
The Album
The other three pieces of the puzzle that were the Dominos were the support players Bobby Whitlock, Carl Radle, and Jim Gordon. Bobby was born in Memphis, Tennessee in March of 1948 to his mother LaVida “Bitsy” King and Jimmy Whitlock, Jimmy was 18 at the time, and LaVida didn’t go through with the marriage. LaVida told tall tales about the mishaps of her great grandmother Rosie when he was a child, recalled Bobby. Bobby was quoted as saying: “I come from River rats, whores, and moonshiners.” Part of Bobby’s lineage was Cherokee, music was a part of Bobby’s childhood as his mother played piano, Hymns and spirituals were often sung to him. But the situation wasn’t perfect, Jimmy was abusive, and LaVida didn’t do much about it. Jimmy was a minister and the family were so poor, members picked cotton. Once Bobby had his first record player, and listened to Elvis, Little Richard and Fats Domino, he learned his ropes in the Memphis scene.
Soon Bobby hung out at the Stax Records, Steve Cropper became a mentor to Bobby during this period, their intertwined history helped them rise further. Jim, Carl and Bobby’s lives would intersect soon enough.
***
Bass player Carl Dean Radle was born in June of 1942 in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Carl had a long association with Leon Russell from the same city, whom talked Carl into moving to Los Angeles around 1960, to be a session player. Carl played with Bobby Rydell for a spell and another band, but gave up being a musician for a period in 1962 to go back to Tulsa and enlisted in the Air Force reserves. Radle was involved with The Playboys, a band that managed a few singles, “Everybody Loves A Clown” and “Count Me In” and got TV attention with Shindig and The Tonight Show. But it folded, and Carl continued on playing sessions for John Lee Hooker and Dobie Gray. When Russell got involved with Delaney and Bonnie, Leon got Carl involved with the band. Russell provided housing for Radle and Whitlock at a planation in Sherman Oaks while he auditioned other players and rehearsed the band for Delaney.
Drummer Jim Beck Gordon was born July 1945 and raised in the San Fernando Valley of Southern California Jim Gordon mostly grew up in Sherman Oaks, Jim’s mother was a paternity nurse, and his father was an accountant who went to A.A. meetings and coached his son’s little league team. Jim made his first drum kit out of trash cans, he was a tubby kid, sensitive about his weight, but still indulged himself until he grew up as a strapping man as an adolescent. He was a class president in Jr. High School, a star musician. While in High school, he was involved with the Burbank Symphony, performed one year in the tournament of Roses parade, and with his High School band got to tour Europe due to a competition, where he meet his sweetheart Jill, in Paris. After high school, he passed up a scholarship to UCLA to begin his professional career as a musician in 1963 at the age of 17. He was a protégé of Hal Blane. He had sessions on The Beach Boys Pet Sounds in 66, Gene Clark and the Gosbin Brothers in 1967, Who Knows Where Time Goes by Judy Collins, The Notorious Byrd Brothers by the Byrds in 1968, and the “Classical Gas” single by Mason Williams in 68. As well as the line up that opened everything up for him, Delaney & Bonnie. But for Gordon, his time with the dominos were the salad days, long before the Schizophrenia that would plague him in later years.
***
It is an interesting thing to note about aspects of Clapton personality: Eric’s purchase of Hurtwood Edge seemed to mirror George’s purchase of Friar Park. Musicians had noted that whomever Clapton was around with, he would start to exhibit trains and habits of the other people – this could have been a biproduct of Clapton’s childhood, but Clapton seems to take an ‘all or nothing’ attitude about everything. It was fate when Pattie took Paula to a Delaney and Bonnie show in Liverpool, when Clapton was touring with him. Paula was seventeen at the time, an aspiring actress, George Harrison was already protective of her, even Pattie admitted that Paula was the prettiest of the sisters, creative, outgoing and not shy like Pattie and Jenny, and Paula was born with an addictive personality as Pattie has admitted. After a drunken night of partying. Clapton fell for Paula: “When the rest of us went back to the hotel, we left Eric and Paula dancing. George was furious with him. He was protective.” Pattie would recall There is a belief that Clapton went for Paula, unconsciously, to get closer to Pattie.
Carl was the one who called Clapton and informed him that Delaney’s band had broken up and would Clapton be interested in working with the drummer, bassist and keyboardist, as Clapton would recall:
“I was in absolute awe of these people, and yet they made me feel like I was on their level. My musicianship fit with their musicianship. We were kindred spirits, made in the same mold.”
The new band set up in Eric’s ‘music room’ on his property and started to jam, mastered old blues favorites and homed in with their new material. Even with its 16-acre space, the neighbors complained and Eric suggested they tone it down. It was also to avoid a potential drug bust by the authorities, or tabloid fodder for the press. Nevertheless, there was a lot of drug use by all of them at Hurtwood Edge. Bobby recalled: “I was with Eric the night he first took heroin. He said it was the only one he hadn’t taken, and he kept going on about Robert Johnson, Ray Charles, You know – If I do it, I’ll get the blues….I was saying ‘You do not need heroin to write the blues. You don’t need that experience.’”
Whitlock would further elaborate on the casual use of drugs and booze during the bulk of the sessions in Miami:
“We didn’t have little bits of anything. There were no grams around – let’s put it like that. Tom couldn’t believe it, the way we had these big bags laying out everywhere. I’m almost ashamed to tell it, but it’s the truth. It was scary, what we were doing, but we were just young and dumb and didn’t know. Cocaine and Heroin, that’s all – and Johnny Walker.”
In spite of that destructive framework, they were gelling as a unit.
The Clapton and Whitlock song writing partnership evolved quickly, as Bobby noted:
“Anyday we just sat down and wrote: Why Does Love Got To Be So Sad – same thing. We started doing the intro on the bottom end of the guitar neck, then Eric whipped up to the top end and it started to sound right. Songs just evolved. We weren’t writing to have great songs; we wrote just to have something to play.”
Clapton has noted the growth of his writing at this period, as well:
“This was an incredibly creative time for me. Driven by my obsession with Pattie, I was writing a lot, and all of the songs I wrote for the Dominos’ first album are really about her and our relationship. Its beginning were inauspicious, because, apart from “Layla”, which was no more than a framework, we actually had very little material.”
Clapton wrote “Bell Bottom Blues” for Pattie, and “I Looked Away”, and he had in mind a few blues covers he wanted to record, but it took time, and the first few weeks weren’t fruitful, but it developed. Bobby’s visit at Clapton’s estate was fortuitious, but Bobby was pretty broke and Eric had to help him out through Robert Stigwood, nevertheless, the six songs, plus Whitlock’s solo number would act as the heartbeat of the album. Eric introduced Stigwood to Whitlock and he was impressed with his star power, but Clapton made it clear that Bobby was going to be in his new band. Bobby stayed on Eric’s estate and caused mischief when Eric was away. During this period Eric got Bobby a new B3 Organ – a demonstration of his confidence in the partnership. Whitlock once described the idea behind the band as followed:
“The basic concept of Derek and the Dominoes – and this was from when Dave Mason was in the group, at the beginning – was that we didn’t want any horns, we didn’t want no chicks. We wanted a Rock N Roll band. But my vocal concept was that we approached the singing like Sam and Dave did: he sings a line, I sing a line, we sing together.”
Even if that idea wasn’t always fully realized, it does explain the vocal interplay between Clapton and Whitlock. The band played a few club shows in England before they headed to Florida and Miami’s Criteria Studios, Dowd had worked with everyone from Coltrane and Aretha Franklin, as well as Cream’s prior albums at that studio. There was a rich history to it all. Tom Dowd was producing Idlewild South, the Allman Brother’s second album, when Clapton wanted to check out the band at a live gig. Allman was around when the call was made to Dowd to get involved with Eric. Duane was a huge fan of Eric, and he had just hoped to meet the man, and watch while Clapton worked. Eric was already aware of Duane’s “Hey Jude” solo and he was equally interested in meeting Duane. Dowd and Eric attended The Allman Bros Band’s Miami concert, Dowd got them in to the show, where the Dominos hid between Barricades and Sandbags on the side of the stage not be seen by the public. When Duane saw Eric at the show, he was awestruck, froze, stopped playing, and Dicky Bettes had to fill in the leads. After the show, Duane headed to Criteria Studio and started to trade licks with Eric, as Dowd noted: “They were trading licks, they were swapping guitars, They were talking shop and information and having a ball – no holds barred, just admiration for each other’s technique and facility.”
Executive Producer Tom Dowd was in for a surprise with his expectations when he started the project, the gear used wasn’t what he expected.
“When I had done the Cream sessions, I’d had to protect Ginger (Baker) from the electrified instruments, because Jack (Bruce) and Eric were using double stacks of Marshalls. So for these sessions Eric walked in with a (small Fender) Champ and a (tiny battery powered) Pignose. He was getting more intimate with his technique, and he’d gone back the other way, in terms of equipment. So we’d set it up with camp chairs holding up amps.”
The intimacy of the sessions add to the smaller venue feel on the record. Duane was often using his Gibson 1957 Les Paul Goldtop, or his 1959 Cherry Sunburst Les Paul. You can often hear the delineation on the record, Gibson’s tend to have a warmer, fuller sound due to their hollow body, and Stratocasters tend to have a more crystalline sound. Clapton was using his Sunburst 1956 Strat, known as the “Brownie” or his makeshift 1950 Stratocaster known as the “Blackie”, and he often used the Fender Champ amp during the sessions. Bobby had noted:
“It was just getting the quality of the sounds – that’s what was important. The Piano had this big boatlike thing on the top of it for a cover, The Leslie was in the sound room, Jim Gordon was in a carousel. It was isolated but open, the amps were in the room, so we got a little of that bleed.”
Even before Duane Allman came into the picture officially, the first three tracks laid down were “I Looked Away, Bell Bottom Blues” and “Keep On Growing”, but Duane’s presence took things to another level.
Once Duane joined the project properly, things began to open up. As Dowd had observed: “That was when the band got serious about what they were doing. All of a sudden, that catalyst was there; it was just a matter of putting things into shape.” Even Bobby has agreed with that assessment: He brought the best of us, even with the songwriting, ‘cause even the songwriting came out of the jamming.” This could be reflected in the Layla Session box set, of the five jams, three were the four piece, and two were with Duane, even most of the Allman Bros Band was on one track.
For example, Duane had a big hand with the slide part for Anyday, where he suggested making it sound like a roman chariot race. The impromptu jams lead to material on the album, the band heard Sam The Sham doing a number in a adjacent room, they liked it enough to where Clapton, Allman, Radle and Whitlock jumped in on Keys On The Highway, Dowd had to jump on it and roll the tapes, hence the fade in. For the sessions of Thorn Tree in The Garden, Dowd had the band play in a circle with a stereo microphone, it was caught live.
Clapton’s connection to Duane was a key to the vibe of the album - once Duane was on board.:
“Duane and I became inseparable during the time we were in Florida, and between the two of us we injected the substance into the Layla sessions that had been missing up to that point. He was like the musical brother I never had but wished I did; more so than Jimi, who was essentially a loner, while Duane was a family man, a brother. Unfortunately for me, he already had a family, but I loved it while it lasted.”
The mixing sessions went rather fast, while the four Dominos went on tour, Dowd went to work, he’d explain: “I sat down and did a rough mix, and lived with it for a couple of days. Then I got serious and remixed the whole thing myself, and sent copies to Eric.” Editors note, I assume he sent audio cassettes for Eric to review. “Then the dominos were doing a concert in Miami and came by to listen to the whole thing. They decided they wanted to remix three or four of the songs, change a part here or there.” Fortunately, they had good notes, mixings would take a few days, unlike modern times, where mixings can take sixteen days now.
Tom Dowd wasn’t initially for the idea of adding on “Layla” the Jim Gordon piano part, a musical part that Rita Coolidge had a hand in, but Dowd went at the challenge: “Layla stood up until the back end, when they wanted to add to the finale. So we had to go back and get as close as we could to the original mix up to the point they liked, then figure out how to cut in this other part. I think we wired two or three tapes together to get the transition the way it was supposed to go, then readjust the front end to fit the back end – there were weeks between the way it was originally recorded and the time we put the back end on.” Much of this sounds similar to the technical wizardry of The Beatles “Strawberry Fields Forever” and “A Day In The Life”.
The album opener, “I Looked Away” is a great tone setter, Eric’s playing with it’s hybrid of country, blues and soul rhythm, the harmonized leads, and his lead work is outstanding, and Bobby’s support vocals keep it interesting. The pleading is enforced with “Bell Bottom Blues”
“Do you want to see me crawl across the floor to you? Do you want to hear me beg you to take me back? I’d gladly do it because, I don’t want to fade away.”
The ballad, “Bell Bottom Blues” mirrors some of the things that were seen with Clapton’s first solo album, Again the rhythm and leads feel inspired, and Bobby’s presence is notable vocally. The robust rocker “Keep On Growing” again mirrors of his solo album, but it’s more refined here, Clapton and Bobby trade vocal leads and one can sense they are equals. Carl’s bass work is melodic and compelling. Clapton’s lead is incendiary here, as well as melodic. Even without Duane’s presence yet, the album’s tone is very clear. The jam that is “Nobody Knows You When You’re Down and Out” is a depression era number from Cox, had written less than two years before his death. The ballad “I Am Yours”, manages to feel sophisticated yet direct. Jim offers some exotic percussion, the organ bedding is tasteful, Clapton plays acoustic and while Duane offers some relaxed slide. The lyrics offered something romantically philosophical.
“Each memory that has left it’s trace on me, Lingers forever as a part of me.”
But the Lyrics to “Anyday” had a desperation to them:
“If you believed in me, like I believe in you, we could have a love so true, we would go on endlessly.”
The question should be raised - was any of this about true love, or about possession?
There’s a certain robust power to Duane’s opening slide on “Anyday”, Bobby’s organ brings the dynamics. There’s a certain desperate need to please the other person, and it feels urgent. Jim’s drumming is excellent as well. Eric and Bobby are in top form with the vocals, The jam that is “Keys To The Highway” began even before the tapes rolled. This Willie Bronzy number was first recorded in 1940. Duane’s fiery slide work comes in at the mid-way point. While Clapton’s lead work comes in around the 6-minute mark.
Disc two opens with the playfulness of “Tell The Truth”, an easy mid-tempo grove builds into the power of chorus. The Phil Spector was a little more frantic. Halfway Bobby is allowed to showcase, “Why Does Love To Be So Sad” is one of the frantic numbers, but a strong melody, Clapton’s brisk rhythm urges Duane’s soling, Carl’s bass work is also impressive here too. Again, there’s an urgency to “So Sad”.
“Like a moth to a flame, Like a song without a name, I’ve never been the same since I met you.”
The slow blues of “Have You Ever Loved A Woman” has Clapton in his element. Hendrix’s “Little Wing” began as a tribute to a living legend, and recorded just prior to Hendrix’s September death became something else. There’s an informal feel to Chuck Willis “It’s Too Late”, much of Bobby’s co-lead vocal eggs Clapton onward. The legendary “Layla” was Clapton’s plea to Pattie. Duane had a big hand in developing the opening fanfare before the verses, and regardless who actually wrote, the second piano section offers up a resolution to the turmoil of the first half, which makes Bobby’s solo closer “Thorn Tree In The Garden” all the more touching, Clapton, Whitlock offered tasteful guitar whole Duane offers the slide support. In the end the album tells and indirect story about longing, turmoil, and possible resolution, but you are left not exactly certain.
Most of the original songs link back into the persistence of “Layla”
“What’ll you do when you get lonely, and nobody’s waiting by your side? You’ve been running and hiding much too long, You know it’s just your foolish pride.”
The album didn’t get much traction upon release; it was a future classic waiting to be discovered. As Dowd noted:
“When we finished it and were mastering it, I felt it was the best goddamn album I’d been involved with since The Genius Of Ray Charles. And Nesuhi, Ahmet Ertegun, and Jerry Wexler were absolutely enamored with the album, but they couldn’t get the goddamn thing on the air, they couldn’t get a single out of it. Nothing, then suddenly it was the national anthem.”
The title track didn’t take off with radio play until 1972.
By Clapton’s admission, the band dissolved: “By the end of the tour, the band was getting very, very loaded, doing way too much.” Even though the band went back to England to record a second album, the paranoia and tension drove them apart. The death of Jimi Hendrix on September 1970 had a huge effect, but then Duane Allman’s death in October 1971 exacerbated it all more: “I remember to this day being in my house, feeling totally lost and hearing Bobby Whitlock pull up in the driveway and scream for me to come out. He sat in his car all day, and I hid.”
Members of the band were so out of it, that when the October 1970 Filmore East show was recorded without the band’s knowledge, and the concert released in 1973, no one knew, Bobby Whitlock was able to get 20,000 dollars from the record label and used it to get a Ferrari. The very thing that inspired Clapton to write “Layla”, the irrational goal, fell apart when it came to Patti Harrison.
Clapton recalled: “I Called her up one afternoon and asked her if she’d like to come over for tea and listen to the new record. Of course it was blatant emotional blackmail and doomed to failure. By this time I had applied a lot of pressure, and this was just more of the same.”
The gesture scared the living daylights out of Pattie, in spite of the flattery. Clapton had already been sending romantic letters to Pattie at Friar Park under another name, which she had initially assumed was a crazed fan until Clapton was direct with her about them. Pattie recalled listening to the album and her song: “He played it to me two of three times, each time watching my face intently for my reaction, My first thought was, Oh God, everyone’s going to know who this is. I felt uncomfortable that he was pushing me in a direction I wasn’t certain I wanted to go.”
There’s the well-known tale that occurred at a London social party hosted by Robert Stigwood, that Clapton confronted Harrison over his devotion over his wife, in front of Patties presence, and George forced Pattie to make a decision, out of an awkward embarrassment in the moment, Pattie left with her husband George. Clapton was already a heroin addict, but he tried to blackmail Pattie further with threats he would become an even great heroin user, if she didn’t go with him. Pattie noted:
“He did as he had threatened. He took the heroin and quickly became addicted. And he took Alice Orsmby-Gore with him. He already did a lot of drugs, but they were the ones we all used – marijuana, uppers, downers, and cocaine – and he drank quite heavily too… He had amassed a big pile and now set about using it. He and Alice retreated into Hurtwood Edge and pulled up the draw bridge. He didn’t leave the house, he didn’t see his friends, he didn’t answer the door or the telephone, and the two of them sank into virtual oblivion.”
What is tragic is that there was material recorded in 1971, and initially Dave Mason was supposed to join the band before Duane got involved. A possible second double album could have been produced with the available material that had been amassed. The Dominos live album recorded in 1971, could have hinted at where the band might have gone, there was a more rhythmic soulful aspect to that live album, dare I say funk, to the performances, and Mason may have changed then dynamic again as the band probably needed another catalyst like Allman. A studio version of “Bottle of Red Wine” could have been a candidate Those five numbers were “Got To Get Better In A Little While, Evil, One More Chance, Mean Old Frisco” and “Snake Lake Blues”, there were other numbers with Allman involved, “Have You Ever Loved A Woman” and “Mean Old World”, or “(When Things Go Wrong) It Hurts Me Too”, the Phil Spector produced “Tell The Truth” and “Roll It Over”. The Clapton / Whitlock songwriting partnership was strong, they could written more material. One of the instrumental jams with Allman could have been given and title and added in, thus if released at the end of 71, could have acted as a tribute to Duane. But will never know.
Pattie would sum up these complicated relationships, thusly:
“What I had felt for George was a great deep love. What Eric and I had was an intoxicating, overpowering passion. It was so intense, so urgent, so heady. I felt almost out of control. Having made the decision to leave my marriage, I knew I had to be with him, go everywhere with him, do everything he did, keep up with him in every way.”
Which eventually meant drinking. Paula was deeply in love with Eric, and when she heard “Layla”, she knew it was about Pattie, and she was heartbroken, she left Eric. Even after the album weas released, Eric kept sending Pattie love letters under an alias, and the two would have clandestine meetings for a period, in spite of his growing isolation. During his hideaway at Huirtwood Edge, friends were worried, David Harlech became so worried about Eric and Alice that he persuaded Pete Townshend to get involved in a charity concert in London for Eric to headline, this was released as the Rainbow Concert with Ronnie Wood, Rich Grech, Steve Winwood, Jim Capaldi in 1973, it got him back to a passion for music. David Harlech was also able to get treatment for Heroin, at least his first attempt. George and Pattie’s relationship was gradually falling apart. In part to due to failed attempts to have a child, and part due to affairs George denied having. Pattie’s final straw with George was discovering he was having an affair with Maureen Starkey, Ringo’s wife. Pattie announced she was leaving George by the start of 1974, in spite of his sad protests. By that year Eric released his second solo album 461 Ocean Boulevard, and Pattie joined the tour.
Eric finally won Pattie, and the 1977 song “Wonderful Tonight” was inspired by her. As much as they would marry in 1979, it wouldn’t be an easy relationship. Eric would continue to have addiction issues, and infidelity issues. But the happy ending was complicated – both Pattie and Eric had addiction issues, and while George had been neglectful towards Pattie, Eric would become psychologically abusive. In the end, Eric didn’t control his demons, he let his demon’s control him. While initially, the tale of their relationship seemed romantic, one could say that Eric saw Pattie, unconsciously, as someone to possess all in the guise of love. Pattie would leave Eric around 1984, and the divorce would be 1988. Pattie ended up feeling just as isolated with Eric as she had when she was with George. It should be noted that in an eighties interview, Clapton made some odd remarks about the Dominos, where he would state, “It was a make-believe band, we were all hiding behind it. Derek and the Dominos – the whole thing was…assumed. So it couldn’t last.” While the context made sense to state it, this seems dismissive of a talented band, and those songs, and in the end, it was Clapton who instigated their dissolvement. A very strange legacy indeed.
Cultural
Impact
Along with The Allman Brothers Band, Derek and the Dominos would have a great influence of many bands. The Marshall Tucker Band and the Tedeschi Trucks band, as well as Black Oak Arkansas, or even Michael Nesmith and the First National Band. Basically, in the 70s, if you heard a dual guitar band, or a balance between guitar virtuosity and song craft, you could trade hints of it to the Dominos. Even eighties Texas guitar hero Stevie Ray Vaughn was a beneficiary of what had come before. In the 70s, a huge beneficiary was southern rock act Lynyrd Skynyrd, who ran after The Allman Brothers Band and the Dominos walked, that is until 1977 with several untimely deaths.
There could be some tenuous comparisons to Bob Dylan’s 1966 motorcycle accident, and Clapton’s isolation from 1971 until 1973. Dylan’s focus seemed very different when he came back to writing, and the fire and drive that compelled Clapton in the last half of the 1960s seemed to have changed after 1970. Eric would still make some fine albums through the 1970s, and most of the 80s, but it wouldn’t feel the same for many. It would be in the late 80s and early 90s that Eric would make a creative resurgence. But Layla and Other Assorted Love Songs would represent a flashpoint, the apex of Clapton’s career. Real life is messy, but one can only hope that the fictional Derek and Layla had a happier ending.
Producer: Derek and the Dominos
Executive Producer: Tom Dowd
Composers: Eric Clapton, Bobby Whitlock, Jimmy Cox*, Nizami**, Charles Segar & Willie Broonzy***, Billy Myles****, Jimi Hendrix*****, Chuck Willis******, Jim Gordon*******
Recording Engineers: Ron Albert, Chuck Kirkpatrick, Howie Albert, Karl Richardson, Mac Emmerman
Cover: Frandsen-De Schonberg
Side One:
I Looked
Away
Bell
Bottom Blues
Keep On
Growing
Nobody
Knows You When Your Down and Out*
Side Two:
I Am Yours
**
Anyday
Key To The
Highway ***
Side Three:
Tell The
Truth
Why Does
Love Got To Be So Sad
Have You Ever Loved A Woman****
Side
Four:
Little
Wing *****
It’s Too
Late ******
Layla
*******
Thorn Tree In The Garden
Book and essays sources: “Layla and other assorted love songs: Derek and the Dominos” By Jan Reid, rock of ages Publishing © 2005
“Clapton: The Autobiography” by Eric Calpton, Published by Three Rivers Press © 2007
“Wonderful Tonight: George Harrison, Eric Clapton and Me” By Pattie Boud with Penny Junor, Published by Three Rivers Press © 2007
Derek and the Dominos: Layla Sessions
box set, essay by Gene Santoro, © 1990
Eric Clapton: Crossroads
box set, essay by Anthony DeCurtis, © 1988
Special Thank you to Abigail Devoe for pushing me to do more with this piece.
Please check out on Spotify, ITunes, Vinyl, or CD if available.
Next Up: George Harrison: All Things Must Pass, coming soon.














