Retro Reviews: Joni Mitchell: Blue

     I decided to launch a new series to imagine myself as a critic at the end of the 60s and start of the 70s, and to rectify certain reviews from Rolling Stone magazine and Creem. This not meant to be contrarian, but to offer a more balanced perspective. All the albums reviewed are indeed classic albums.

Joni Mitchell – Blue (1971)

*****

Producer: Joni Mitchell

Musicians: Joni Mitchell, James Taylor, Russ Kunkel, Stephen Stills, Sneaky Pete Klienow

Songs: All I Want, My Old Man, Little Green, Carey, Blue, California, This Flight Tonight, River, A Case Of You, The Last Time I Saw Richard

Reviewed by Matthew Anthony Allair

    The theme of regret and reflection seems to be the persistent thread on Joni Mitchell’s outstanding album Blue. Four tracks use the dulcimer played by Joni to great effect, “All I Want, Carey, California” and “A Case Of You.” Her piano work remains outstanding, and her angelic voice remains the glue that ties this all together. There may be a little ornamentation as far as horns to flute, but the added percussion, a touch of bass, and extra guitars serve the material well. James Taylor and Stephen Stills make another appearance. There’s an honesty, candor and a sweetness that isn’t built on resentment, but resignation at various points. This is the kind of material one could need when they seek something meditative yet relaxing. Her production, while modest, archives intimacy and a relatability to the songs. The songs seems to run the gambit of friendships and lost loves.

    The aural vibrantly is there with the opener “All I Want”, a track that Mr. Taylor provides second guitar, but the Dulcimer drives the tone of the track. The longing of the lyrics about traveling onward in the midst of an ambivalent relationship latches onto the listener. The piano on “My Old Man” has a rich tapestry and the kind of harmonic complexity you come to expect, about a couple who aren’t bound by the convention of marriage, as well acknowledging the emptiness when separate. The acoustic work of “Little Green” almost hints at “Morning Morgantown”, but it develops into a more bitter sweet tone with a haunting or haunted quality. The bass And light percussion of “Carey”, along with the dulcimer, offers a whimsy over a complicated relationship. The title track, “Blue” closes the first half with some impressionistic piano. This song seems to be about the consequences of too much, too much indulgence, too much need in lieu of a healthy relationship.

    The second half opens with the acoustic whimsy of “California”, and some nice pedal steel guitar that responds to the lyric. There’s already growing mythos over the California folk and country scene that is unfolding and this seems to touch on this. There’s a dark tone musically to “This Flight Tonight”, but there’s an ambiguity and ambivalence to the lyrics, there’s a nice nod transistor radio rockabilly over a few lyrics. “River” is simply magical as a piano driven song, set around the holidays, it’s a kind of thematic hymn to childhood memories of winter adventures. Which is often the case, her best songs are often near the end of an album, “A Case Of You” is such a song, a piece about the deep connection that isn’t going to quite work out. The closing Piano piece, “The Last Time I Saw Richard” is a meditation - a reflection on a past relationship that has given the female partner a reality check, or perhaps they simply knew each other too well, but this paints a very vivid picture. 

    The consistency with Mitchell’s artistry, her work as a singer and musician, has remained impressive with four albums under her belt. Rumor has it, that she is going to sign with another label, and one could view these first four albums as the close of the first chapter, her growth is astonishing and I await the next phase. She is on par with contemporary Dylan, perhaps even surpassing him for the time being. That is a heady statement to make, but it bears fruit to argue it after this release.